Jura and Breville are two of the biggest coffee machine brands on the market today. They both produce exceptional coffee makers at a range of price points. Both being so popular, there are a lot of different angles and opinions in the battle of Jura vs Breville.
In general, Jura espresso machines are better if you’re looking for the ultimate in convenience with amazing design and flavorful coffee drinks. On the other hand, Breville coffee machines generally require more user input but the payoff is greater customization. Plus, they have more budget-friendly options.
There’s a lot to unpack between the two coffee giants: history, technology, reliability. Then there’s the head-to-head battle between their flagship espresso machines. So let’s jump right in as we take a deep dive into all the details of this premium caffeinated showdown.
This article may contain affiliate/ compensated links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you. For more information please see our disclaimer here.
One of the biggest differences between Jura from Breville espresso machines is the milk options:
The entry-level Jura machines do not have any way of steaming milk – wand or otherwise. Whereas all the Breville espresso machines do.
On the entry-level Breville offerings, you will get a manual steam wand. So you’ll need to sharpen your barista skills to get that perfect foam, but the option is still there.
When you get into the higher-end options, Jura coffee machines offer automatic milk steaming. This usually offers some form of customization although it can be quite limited. Breville also offers automatic milk frothing with their higher-end machines, but the manual option always remains.
If you’re someone who is proud of their latte art skills, you can still have a top-of-the-range Breville make your espresso whilst you froth your milk manually. Jura, however, takes the process entirely out of your hands, providing milk for your selected coffee drink at the touch of a button.
Semi-Automatic vs Super-Automatic
As super-automatic espresso machines, Jura’s are built to make everything as easy as possible.
You select your coffee and the machine does the rest. There are some models that require the quite frankly outrageous hassle of moving your cup a few inches to the right to pour the milk in. But that is as difficult as it gets.
Breville has gone in a very different direction with their semi-automatic espresso machines:
Even the top-of-the-range coffee machines require your involvement to some degree. On some models, it’s as simple as moving the portafilter from point A to point B. On others, you are in charge of most elements. In general, this gives you more control and greater customization however, it does mean they aren’t “one button” espresso makers.
Cleaning & Maintenance
Are you a “little and often” or “occasional but thorough” type cleaner?
Jura coffee machines “self-clean” after every use so you only need to do a deep clean every few months. This is simple to do and the machine will guide you through all the steps. Although this does involve buying Jura branded cleaning materials.
Beville uses the portafilter design meaning you need to clean it out after every use yourself. This is as simple as emptying the grounds and rinsing the portafilter. But it needs to be done.
We should also mention that some coffee experts doubt how clean the Jura brewgroup is. It can’t be removed for cleaning and it doesn’t take much for nasty things to grow in a warm and wet environment. However, Jura’s reputation and hordes of great reviews suggest that this isn’t an issue. That said, if you want to be certain your machine is sparkling clean, the Breville is the better option as you can deep clean the portafilter and brewhead as often as you like.
The biggest limiting factor in almost all purchasing decisions is how much it’s going to cost you.
Neither Jura or Breville are “budget-friendly” coffee brands. But the entry-level Breville machine is around $400 whereas the entry-level Jura is double that, and it doesn’t steam milk.
For those looking for maximum functionality for their money, Breville is the clear winner. They sell many excellent espresso machines for under $1000 that can make all types of espresso drinks to a very high standard. Prices top out around $2500 for one of the best espresso machines you could possibly imagine (the Oracle Touch).
For those looking for ease along with quality and have the money to spend, Jura offers incredible design, amazing coffee, and the easiest possible user experience. You can do it all from your phone for some of their more expensive machines too. You will get one-touch perfect coffee – milk and all – for pretty much any coffee style imaginable. Just at a price.
Leo Henzriohs started Jura Elektroapparate AP in 1931 as a home appliance company. But it wasn’t until the 1980s that Jura started making coffee machines. Now, that’s all they make, focusing on high-end products that produce the best coffee quality with the least amount of effort.
By focusing solely on super-automatic espresso machine manufacturing, Jura’s specialization and reputation for superior design and build quality are world-renowned. Whilst there are no “budget” Jura coffee machines, they do work flawlessly and look fantastic. In our opinion, this makes Jura coffee machines worth the money – just as long as your bank balance can stretch in the first place.
Breville was started in 1932 by two Australians, Bill O’Brien and Harry Norville. Just like Jura, the original business model wasn’t as a coffee machine manufacturer. They actually started out making radios and made mine detectors during World War II.
It wasn’t until the early 2000s that Breville started making coffee machines. But, since then, they have quickly developed a reputation for selling high-quality coffee makers. Unlike Jura, they haven’t stopped manufacturing other home appliances like blenders and sandwich makers.
Breville also doesn’t focus solely on the top end of the coffee machine market. They have a wide range of coffee products from grinders to more traditional coffee machines like drip brewers. Pricing wise, they start at more of a mid-range level and go all the way up to the Oracle Touch – their flagship super automatic espresso machine.
Breville or Sage: What’s the Difference?
In the UK and European markets, all Breville espresso machines are available to buy but they are marketed and sold under a different name: Sage.
However, you will find some coffee makers in the UK with Breville branding but these are NOT associated with the “Breville Group Ltd” like the Sage machines. Although the name is the same, the Breville branded brewers in the UK come from a separate company called “Jarden Corp”. Since the Breville name already existed in the market, the Breville Group Ltd decided to launch under the Sage name in Europe.
Jura Coffee Machine Technology
Jura coffee makers are filled with proprietary technology. Each has a fancy acronym but, at the end of the day, they are all designed to get the best from your coffee beans. Some are just fancy names for fairly pedestrian processes that several comparable automatic coffee machines offer, whilst others are genuinely very impressive.
Aroma G3 Grinder
This is the most recent version of Jura’s built-in grinder, cutting grinding time in half.
Sounds really impressive but lets remember that grinding coffee for 1 espresso takes 2-3 seconds with an electric grinder. So cutting that to 1-2 seconds isn’t saving you a ton of time unless you make like 1000 coffees a day. It’s a great coffee grinder though, just ignore the time-saving marketing hype.
CLEARYL Plus Filter CartridgeJura’s proprietary water filter cartridge is designed to stop the thermoblock boilers from getting blocked with mineral deposits. It means you don’t have to descale your Jura machine as often as you otherwise would.
But it is just a water filter. There are many other coffee machines out there with excellent water filters that will do the same job. Again, it’s good to have but not exactly game changing.
Intelligent Pre-Brew Aroma System (I.P.B.A.S.)Your Jura automatic coffee maker will instinctively use the correct amount of water to allow the grounds to bloom before brewing. This is where the trapped gases escape and is essential to getting the most flavorful cup of coffee.
This is very cool and genuinely different from the average espresso machine. A lot of super automatics won’t have this stage in their brewing process and it is one of the reasons the Jura machines can pull such amazing espresso.
Pulse Extraction Process (P.E.P.)Another unique technology that actually makes a difference.
It works exactly how you think it will – the hot water is pushed through the grounds in bursts to give perfect extraction times. As extraction is the most important part of the coffee brewing process, this pulse method results in the ultimate coffee quality.
Breville Coffee Machine Technology
Breville operates in a more old-fashioned sense when it comes to coffee machine technology. You won’t find any fancy systems or “innovative” solutions. Just exceptionally well-designed and superbly built coffee machines.
This may seem like a downgrade after the tech-fest of Jura, but making great coffee doesn’t have to be complicated. All over the world, there are people doing it with a manual espresso machine, manual coffee grinder, and a simple kettle from a tiny cart.
Breville’s top-end machines still have pre-infusion, great extraction, superb grinders, and all the bits you need for exceptional coffee. They just haven’t tried to re-invent the wheel with any of it.
- 11” x 13.8” x 17.3”
- 15 pre-programmed drinks
- Once preferences are selected, no user input is required
- 7 grind settings
- 3 water temperature settings
- Uses Jura branded cleaning products
Design & Build Quality
The Jura S8 automatic coffee machine is beautifully crafted. Sleek and elegant, with options for stainless steel or black finish. The touch screen display is sharp and easy to use and, overall, the machine looks like a premium coffee spaceship with great caffeination available at the touch of a button.
The S8 is big – 11” x 13.8” x 17.3” – all that technology has to go somewhere. So you’re going to need some serious counter space to accommodate it. It weighs 22lbs but since I can’t imagine anyone is planning to move this thing around regularly that isn’t a huge deal, just something to think about if you have to carry it to the top floor.
Jura machines are built to last and the S8 is no exception. With the water filters and regular descaling, this machine will last 5-10 years. You can also get it serviced by registered Jura technicians once a year if you like, which may extend the lifespan beyond even this.
Breville Oracle Touch
The Oracle Touch has been designed to look like a classic espresso machine. You have your portafilter, milk steaming wand, and bean hopper all clearly on display. I personally prefer this to the big box with spouts design but that’s a purely personal preference. The touch screen is beautifully rendered and easy to use too.
The Breville Oracle Touch espresso machine is also big. It’s even bigger than the S8 at 14.5” x 14.7” x 17.6” and weighs a staggering 37lbs. If you have a big kitchen and no intention of moving it, this shouldn’t matter too much.
Breville coffee machines last a long time, and the commitment to quality engineering is superb. Compared to the S8, there are a lot fewer moving parts. Whilst that doesn’t guarantee a longer lifespan, there are certainly fewer things that can go wrong.
For me, the Breville is a better-looking machine than the S8 – I like my coffee machine to look like a coffee machine. But this is purely a personal preference. Since both are known for high coffee machine durability, round 1 is a draw.
Ease of Use
Jura Coffee Machine S8
Jura machines are designed to be as easy to use as a coffee machine possibly can be while still delivering exactly what you want – the ultimate quality coffee.
Using the simple touch screen, you can choose:
- Your preferred coffee drink
- Milk frothiness
Once you have perfected your brew, the S8 will save your customized settings for later. This is one-touch coffee drinks at their finest. As the milk texture is adjusted with a level above the nozzle, you’ll need to remember your preferred setting if there are a few of you using the machine with different preferences.
Breville Oracle Touch
The Oracle Touch is similar to the S8 in that you use a touch screen display to choose your favorite coffee. You can then cycle through the customizable options and save your preferences for later.
However, there is more involved in the brewing process as you need to move the portafilter after the coffee has been ground and tamped to the brewhead. Plus you need to add milk to the jug for frothing.
This may be too much of an annoyance for those looking for ultimate convenience, which is fair enough. But it does allow for more customization. Plus it has the added bonus of making the whole process feel like you’re a master Barista that can make perfect coffee with ease.
The S8 is undoubtedly an easier machine to use than the Oracle Touch. It’s incredibly simple with minimal effort required to get your perfect coffee. Whilst the Oracle Touch is still very simple, there are just more steps involved in getting your preferred coffee. This is generally true of all Breville coffee machines – they prefer a more involved coffee experience.
Psst… Want to compare the Breville Oracle Touch to the Barista Touch? Check out our comparison article here:
Jura Espresso Machine S8
The S8 has 7 grind settings, 10 coffee strength settings, 3 water temperature settings, adjustable water and milk volume, and adjustable milk foam. That’s a lot of customization options.
In fact, there are 210 possible coffee outcomes for each of the 12 coffee options simply by adjusting the grind setting, water temperature, and strength.
Everything except the milk foam can be adjusted through the touchscreen or via Jura’s app, which is great. The app even works on an Apple watch so you can brew a coffee with a touch of your wrist, if you like. It’s almost impossible to imagine that you won’t be able to produce EXACTLY what you want from this coffee machine.
Breville Oracle Touch
The Oracle Touch takes customization to an entirely different level. It’s what makes it one of the best Breville espresso machines you can buy.
Starting with a whopping 45 grind settings, you can then adjust the temperature in 2°F increments, plus the weight of coffee up to 22g. Add to that adjustable milk temperature, foam texture, and milk to foam ratio, and you have a frankly insane level of control.
With all this control, you may feel that you’ll just get confused. We can’t guarantee that you won’t but you can at least save 8 drinks to simply select from at a later date which takes away some of the stress. The steaming wand can also be used manually for the control freaks like me.
If you want to fiddle with the minutiae of your coffee selection, this is the machine for you.
The customization options on the Breville Oracle Touch are staggering, giving you near total control of your coffee brewing. The S8 is easier to customize but has a much smaller range of choices, though they are certainly not lacking.
Ease of Cleaning
S8 by Jura
Jura’s commitment to being as easy as possible to use extends to cleaning your coffee maker. This automatic espresso machine will let you know when it needs descaling and take you through the process step by step, using Jura branded cleaning products of course.
The brewgroup can’t be removed to be cleaned, which some feel means it will never be properly clean. There doesn’t appear to be any issues with this though so we can safely assume that the internal cleaning processes do the job very well.
Oracle Touch by Breville
The Oracle Touch is also exceptionally easy to clean but is more of a “little and often” clean rather than the occasional deep clean that the Jura requires. The big advantage of the portafilter system is that there is no danger of nasty stuff building up in your brewer as it can be quickly cleaned after each use.
You also don’t need to pay for expensive cleaning supplies to run “descaling” cycles every so often. The Oracle Touch needs less maintenance as there are fewer moving parts on the inside of the machine. Just dismantle and clean the grinder every week or so and make sure the milk wand stays clean and you’ll be fine.
Both super automatic espresso machine makes cleaning as simple as possible. It all comes down to whether you would prefer one big deep clean every so often, or more frequent cleans that take just a few minutes.
And the Winner Is…
The question is, do you want ease or customization?
If you want great coffee as easily as possible then the Jura S8 automatic coffee machine is the one for you. It is super simple to use – just push a button and get with extremely good espresso.
The Breville Oracle Touch is one of the best coffee machines available if you want to be more involved in brewing your espresso. Especially if you want to fiddle with settings to get the best from your favorite single-origin espresso beans.
The coffee quality is indistinguishable, they are two of the finest coffee machines money can buy. So it really boils down to how you want to use the machine day to day. Few coffee machines offer this kind of quality, customization, and great looks. They’re both fantastic.
- 9.4” x 12.7” x 17.5”
- Available in Piano Black or Piano White
- No milk frothing
- Makes espresso, ristretto, or lungo
- Uses Jura branded cleaning products
Design and Build Quality
The A1 is sleek, simple, and beautiful.
Great lines, simplistic and elegant design, available in a choice of black or white. Overall, it’s one of the best-looking home coffee machines you can buy – a talking point of any kitchen.
Considering the entry-level status, it’s still pretty big. Measuring in at 9.4” x 12.7” x 17.5”, the depth means it will need some counter space, even if it isn’t too wide or tall. All that tech has to fit somewhere after all. That said, by super-automatic espresso machine standards, this is still a compact machine.
Jura’s reputation for build quality is hard-earned and the A1 is no exception. With proper cleaning, it should easily be brewing awesome espresso for 5-10 years and look great whilst doing it.
Breville Barista Pro
Breville’s preference for making café-style espresso machines can be seen in the Barista Pro which I like, but it won’t be for everyone.
What’s great about the Barista Pro is that it comes in a choice of 9 colors. The bad news is that all except the brushed stainless steel and black are more expensive. But it’s nice to have the options.
The Barista Pro is also a big machine. Measuring 13.9” x 13.5” x 16”, it takes up a significantly larger portion of your kitchen than the A1. If you’re limited on counter space this could be a problem but for those with the space, it’s still relatively compact when compared to the offerings of other coffee machine brands.
Breville also makes robust coffee machines that are built to last. With very few moving parts compared to the Jura machines, there is less that can potentially go wrong. So, you can reasonably expect a similar 5-10 year lifespan from the Barista Pro – possibly even longer.
Jura espresso machines are frequent recipienets of design awards so it’s hard to argue with the sleek looks of the A1. As build quality is a hallmark of both coffee brands, they both come out equal there. So, the Jura A1 wins this category purely based on superior looks.
The Breville Barista Pro, however, gets bonus points for being available in a range of colors – not something offered by most coffee machines at this price point.
Ease of Use
If Jura does one thing well it’s making super easy to use super-automatic espresso machines. So, the A1 really couldn’t be easier to use. As it only makes 3 types of coffee anyway, you just push the buttons on the top to select what you want and cycle through the options for changing the strength and water volume.
Once your settings are saved, it’s just a one-button machine for pulling ristretto, espresso, and lungo. Coffee brew cycles don’t get any easier than that.
Breville Barista Pro
The Barista Pro has more customizable options than the A1. This means there’s a little more work involved and it’s slightly more complex to get used to, if only because there are more things to choose from. However, the LCD screen clearly displays your current settings and instructions making it very easy to choose the options you’re after.
Whether this style of coffee brewing is better depends on whether you want to be able to customize different coffee drinks or if you are just looking for simplicity.
In the battle for simplicity, the A1 wins hands down.
But it does also have fewer options so there are sacrifices for that extra ease of use. Being the best Jura coffee machine for black coffee lovers, if this is you, the A1 is the clear winner. But, if you want milk frothing and more customization, simplicity doesn’t mean anything as you won’t have those options.
The Jura A1 doesn’t offer a lot in terms of options, but then it isn’t meant to:
You get two strength options, then you can adjust the water volume from 0.5 oz up to just under 3 oz. Designed to do one thing perfectly is the A1’s calling card – make espresso, lungo, or ristretto. So, if you’re an avid espresso fan, you don’t need anything else to get a great shot of coffee.
Breville Barista Pro
The Barista Pro offers a lot more customization options.
There are 30 grinder settings, then you can adjust the strength, pre-infusion time, extraction time, and temperature. So you can make a lot more different coffee drinks with the Breville Barista Pro than its competitor from Jura.
Dialing in the coffee you want is definitely possible. It just might take some fiddling with settings.
The Breville Barista Pro is a vastly superior coffee maker in terms of customization options. Even if all it had was the milk wand, it would still offer more than the A1. That’s the market that Jura was aiming for, of course, but when we are stacking up the range of options, the Barista Pro is in a different league.
Ease of Cleaning
Jura A1 Espresso Machine
Like everything else with the A1, cleaning is mostly automatic and incredibly easy. The espresso machine does it all for you on a daily basis and will let you know when a deep clean is required.
Carrying out a deep clean does involve using branded cleaning products. And it comes with the caveat that the brewgroup can’t be removed so it begs the question as to whether it is adequately cleaned. But it all seems to work great and thousands of happy customers can’t be wrong.
Breville Barista Pro
The portafilter design of the Barista Pro makes cleaning very easy. Just remember it needs to be done after every use to keep it in top condition.
Milk frothing wands can get very dirty very quickly. So you need to stay on top of cleaning the wand to make sure it doesn’t get blocked. Overall though, it’s still a very easy machine to keep clean.
They’re both really easy to clean, but the Jura is ridiculously low maintenance so has to take the W here too. This was a close race though. The only real reason the Breville is harder to clean is that it has a milk wand – extra features mean extra cleaning.
And the Winner is…
If all you want to drink are espressos or black lungo coffee, the Jura A1 is the clear winner. You’ll get exceptional coffee without all the bits you don’t need.
For literally everyone else, the Breville Barista Pro is the standout. It has a milk wand for a start. This alone even will make it the better option for many people.
The level of customization is far beyond what the A1 can offer. Every negative of Breville’s Barista Pro vs the Jura A1 is caused by it having more features allowing it to do more things. This extra features are obviously only good if you actually use those things.
The A1 is for the espresso drinker who wants an amazing coffee machine to automatically make their perfect espresso shot. The Barista Pro is for literally everyone else.
Whilst you can select your coffee with the touch of a button on some models, you always need to move the portafilter yourself. Other coffee machine brands seem to worry a lot more about offering a “super-automatic” option than Breville do.
This isn’t necessarily a bad thing – maybe (like me) you like to be in control and feel like a barista when making your coffee.
But it’s not for everyone. If you just want to pick your favorite coffee drink and have the machine do the rest, Jura coffee makers are the better option.
Breville is targeted more at people who want to be involved in the coffee-making process. Who want to tweak the grinder settings and the water temperature. People who feel their espresso would benefit from an extra 3g of coffee and 2 degrees of water temperature. Also for those whose budget doesn’t quite stretch to Jura levels but still want great coffee from a great looking machine.
The winner of the Jura vs Breville battle really comes down to personal preference in how you want to make your espresso. Breville is the clear choice under $1000 as you get much more for your money. Anything over this is down to you.
You Might Also Like
Designed with novice espresso makers in mind, this Breville Barista Express Impress review assesses how impressive this machine really is
Whether you see Sage vs Breville depends on where you’re shopping – discover why it’s Sage in Europe but Breville everywhere else